Tim McCarver vs. John Madden

I’m having a hard time deciding which announcer gets on my nerves more.

Tim McCarver

  • “I got my ’splitter’ and my ‘plate’ mixed up and kind of called it a ’splate.’ It’s a new word I made up.”
  • “A walk is as good as a home run.”
  • “If the double play is a pitcher’s best friend, what is a fielder’s choice? An acquaintance?”
  • “National league pitchers pitch Edmonds up and in. That is his strength and his weakness.”
  • “If football is a game of inches then baseball is a game of inch.”
  • “Yankee pitchers have had great success this year against Cabrera when they get him out.”

John Madden

  • “The fewer rules a coach has, the fewer rules there are for players to break.”
  • “It’s kind of hard to keep your head from being lopsided if you have half of the field in your helmet.”
  • “You can only make one play at a time.”
  • “Winning is a great deoderant.”
  • “First down is a good down.”
  • “Of course, if he had had control of the ball when he hit the ground, then it would have been a complete pass.”

John Madden wins in a Googlefight between the two.


Comments

  1. 1. Paul
    10/28/2004 at 10:33am

    Great thread. This is a question that will be debated for ages. I’d like to see how Paul Maguire fits into the mix. He’s a doozie!

  2. 2. Deke
    10/28/2004 at 10:45pm

    Which one gets on your ‘nevers’ more?

    Madden rules!!

Leave a Reply